Sicilys Pizza Reviews
Sicilys Pizza has an overall rating of 4.3 based on 94 reviews. Customer feedback on Sicilys Pizza is mixed: Sicilys Pizza reviewers highlight positive aspects like delicious pizza, friendly staff, quick service, generous portions, which strongly appeal to families, pizza lovers, local residents, casual diners. However, Sicilys Pizza is often criticized for its inconsistent quality, limited menu options, higher prices, long wait times during peak hours.
94 reviews
5 Stars
18
4 Stars
10
3 Stars
2
2 Stars
3
1 Star
0
How would you rate Sicilys Pizza?
All Sicilys Pizza Reviews (94)
hello_sam065
May 26, 2026
"Generous with the toppings"
A friend recommended sicilyspizza.com, so I gave it a try last night, and I’m glad I did. They really don’t skimp on the toppings. My pepperoni pizza had plenty on every slice instead of just a few scattered pieces, and the veggies were loaded without making the whole thing messy. It actually felt like I got my money’s worth. I’d definitely order from them again.
0
Reply
jasper_Markow76
May 17, 2026
"I love how easy it is…"
I love how easy it is to pick my toppings, and crust, without any hassle. My order showed up just the way I wanted it, it made the whole thing really simple
0
Reply
lloyd_Beebe92
May 13, 2026
"The pizza was bland, and…"
The pizza was bland, and the crust was kind of soggy, which was ridiculous considering I was really looking forward to it. I don’t think I’d order from here again anytime soon
0
Reply
hello_ollie546
May 07, 2026
"Late-Night Pizza Lifesaver"
I ordered from Sicily’s Pizza super late after work, i was basically ready to cry tears of joy just seeing they were still open. Everything else around me was closed, so they immediately became heroes in my book. The pizza was decent, still warm when it arrived, and it totally hit the spot. Delivery took a little longer than I was hoping, but since it was late, I really can’t complain too much. I’d definitely order again when I’m starving at night and need food to save my soul.
0
Reply
Robert.catapano
April 30, 2026
"Half the Menu Was Unavailable Again"
I went in expecting to order my usual stuff, but once again like half the menu wasn’t available, which is getting frustrating because it feels like every time I try to give this place another shot there’s something they’re out of or can’t make, and I just end up having to pick something I didn’t really want.
0
Reply
nakia_Santana76
April 29, 2026
"Easy pizza order"
I ordered from sicilyspizza.com and it was easy. The menu loaded quick, and I didnt have to click around forever to find what I wanted. Checkout was simple too. It wasnt anything fancy, but it worked well and made ordering pizza painless
0
Reply
john2003
April 23, 2026
"Order was 100% spot on"
My pizza order came exactly right, no question about it. The toppings were all there, the sauces were correct, and literally nothing was missing. It’s a simple thing, but that’s exactly what I wanted, and they absolutely nailed it...
0
Reply
Pamela_elerson76
April 22, 2026
"The pizza was really tasty and…"
The pizza was really tasty and brought back that cozy feeling of grabbing a hot slice after a long day. Delivery took a little longer than I expected, so I was getting hungry by the time it arrived, but once I opened the box and smelled it, I was happy
0
Reply
todd-Anderson
April 18, 2026
"Pretty nice little spot"
The place had a nice vibe overall, and after a few minutes inside, it felt comfy. I’d say it’s the kind of spot you can settle into fairly easily.
0
Reply
Michael.gilchrist
April 17, 2026
"I ordered pickup from Sicily’s Pizza and…"
I ordered pickup from Sicily’s Pizza and it was a good experience. Their website is easy enough to use and my order go through without any issue. I got there a little early and the pizza was already almost done, so that was nice. The staff was friendly too, not super chatty or anything, just quick and polite. By the time I got home the pizza was still hot and it taste fresh. Crust was good as well. I’d definitely order pickup from them again
0
Reply
JaneLloyd
April 15, 2026
"They Messed Up My Order, but At Least They Fixed It"
I was annoyed because they mixed up my order, and that’s definitely on them. I don’t get how it happened, but at least they fixed it quickly and were nice about it instead of making excuses. The pizza ended up being good, so I’m not totally mad, but they really need to pay better attention.
0
Reply
hello_andy137
April 04, 2026
"Handled Better Than I Expected"
I noticed a wrong charge on my order and reached out to them about it. It did take a little while to get a response, but I was pleasantly surprised that they refunded me without turning it into a hassle. It wasn’t perfect, but they handled it fairly, and I’d be comfortable ordering from them again.
0
Reply
thomas1985
April 03, 2026
"Solid portions and fair prices"
I’ve ordered from Sicily’s Pizza a couple times now, and honestly, the portions are solid. The prices feel fair too, especially when you’re trying to feed the whole family, it actually feels worth it
0
Reply
janice_Butler02
March 31, 2026
"The pizza got here quickly, so it…"
The pizza got here quickly, so it was still nice and hot when I opened the box. No complaints from me.
0
Reply
tomdorch7613
March 27, 2026
"Decent Options, But I Kind of Wish I’d Chosen Differently"
Sicily’s Pizza has a decent menu with pizza, pasta, wings, and a few sides, so there’s definitely something for everyone. I did like that it wasn’t just the usual basic pizza choices. That said, I kind of regret not looking over the menu more carefully because some of it felt a little random, and not everything sounded all that exciting. It’s fine for a group order, but I do wish the menu was clearer and a bit more put together.
0
Reply
hello_willis464
March 24, 2026
"Super Easy Order and Friendly Service"
Ordered from Sicily’s Pizza last night and had a really good experience. The whole process was easy from start to finish. The person on the phone was friendly and patient with my questions, and the delivery driver was really nice too. Nothing felt rushed or complicated, which I appreciated. I’d definitely order from them again.
0
Reply
hello_jeffery858
February 27, 2026
"Late Twice, But Still Decent"
I’ve ordered pizza from here a couple times now, and both times it showed up later than they said it would. Not wildly late, but late enough that I started doing that thing where you keep checking your phone like it’s going to make the driver appear faster. Anyway, the pizza was still warm when it got here, so it wasn’t a total loss. I was already halfway distracted watching some random cooking video by then, which is funny because I was literally waiting for food. Overall, not perfect, but the pizza itself was fine once it arrived
0
Reply
CharlesStakkeland
February 24, 2026
"Really appreciated the quick help"
They helped me so quickly, and that made a big difference. I was starting to feel a little stressed, so getting fast support really put me at ease. Super grateful for how smoothly everything went
0
Reply
JohnRaley
February 22, 2026
"Pretty solid little pizza spot"
I stopped by Sicily’s Pizza sometime last weekend the place just seemed really clean overall. The tables were wiped down, the floor didn’t have that gross sticky feel, and the counter area looked tidy. Even the bathroom was clean, which I always kind of peek at lol. The food came out nice and hot, and the whole place just felt like someone actually cared about it. Definitely like a 5-star visit for me.
0
Reply
CHAMPINE
February 17, 2026
"The cheese was really good. Fresh taste…"
The cheese was really good. Fresh taste. Super melty. That kind of simple thing that just makes the whole bite better
0
Reply
Have a question about Sicilys Pizza?
Log in to ask your Sicilys Pizza question!
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
